The miscibility of polypropylene (PP) melts in which the chains differ only
in stereochemical composition has been investigated by two different proce
dures. One approach used detailed local information from a Monte Carlo simu
lation of a single chain, and the other approach takes this information fro
m a rotational isomeric state model devised decades ago, for another purpos
e. The first approach uses PRISM theory to deduce the intermolecular packin
g in the polymer blend, while the second approach uses a Monte Carlo simula
tion of a coarse-grained representation of independent chains, expressed on
a high-coordination lattice. Both approaches find a positive energy change
upon mixing isotactic PP (iPP) and syndiotactic PP (sPP) chains in the mel
t. This conclusion is qualitatively consistent with observations published
recently by Mulhaupt and co-workers. The size of the energy change on mixin
g is smaller in the MC/PRISM approach than in the RIS/MC simulation, with t
he smaller energy change being in better agreement with the experiment. The
RIS/MC simulation finds no demixing for iPP and atactic polypropylene (aPP
) in the melt, consistent with several experimental observations in the lit
erature. The demixing of the iPP/sPP blend may arise from attractive intera
ctions in the sPP melt that are disrupted when the sPP chains are diluted w
ith aPP or iPP chains.