Ag. Lebed et N. Hayashi, Paramagnetic-like destructive mechanism against superconductivity in Sr2RuO4: a triplet scenario versus a singlet one, PHYSICA C, 341, 2000, pp. 1677-1678
The most popular description of superconductivity phenomenon in Sr2RuO4r is
based on a so-called single-band (usually gamma -band) "isotropic p-wave o
rder parameter". In a magnetic field parallel to the conducting planes, suc
h triplet "isotropic p-wave phase" is not destroyed by the Clogston-Chaldra
sekhar paramagnetic limiting field and can be destroyed only by the Meissne
r currents (i.e., the orbital effects). We analyze the orbital destructive
effects against superconductivity for in-plane magnetic field (when electro
n orbits are open) and find that H-c2(//)(0) similar or equal to 0.75 T-c(d
H(c2)(//)(T)/dT)(Tc) (which is a little bigger than the Werthamer-Helfand-H
ohenberg value for an isotropic 3D case). We point out that the experimenta
lly determined ratio H-c2(//)(0)/T-c(dH(c2)(//)(T)/dT)(Tc) similar or equal
to 0.44 - 0.5 in Sr2RUO4 is significantly less than the calculated value 0
.75. Since the upper critical field, H-c2(//)(T), is a well experimentally
defined quantity in Sr2RUO4 (unlike high-T-c superconductors) we conclude t
hat the single-band triplet "isotropic p-wave order parameter" seems to be
inappropriate description of superconductivity in this material. Two possib
ilities are discussed: 1) Three-band nature of triplet superconductivity; 2
) Singlet (d-wave) nature of superconducting pairing tin this case, the des
tructive actions of both the orbital effects and the Clogston-Chandrasekhar
paramagnetic effects result in an agreement with the experimentally observ
ed value of H-c2(//)(0)/Tc(dH(c2)(//)(T)/dT)(Tc)).