C. Poteaux et P. Berrebi, GENOME INTEGRITY AND TROUT STOCKING IN TH E MEDITERRANEAN BASIN, Bulletin francais de la peche et de la pisciculture, (344-45), 1997, pp. 309-322
The stocking practices used for brown trout (Salmo trutta) in the Sout
h of France result in secondary contact and introgression between popu
lations from two genetically differentiated forms of the same species
(KRIEG and GUYOMARD, 1985; GUYOMARD, 1989) : domesticated stocks that
originate from the Atlantic form and the wild Mediterranean population
s. This paper reviews the protein data for 44 Mediterranean samples ex
amined in the laboratory, with an appraisal of introgression by the do
mesticated form and a description of the genetic consequences of stock
ing on the existing populations. The samples were collected from sever
al French departments : Pyrenees Orientates (12 stations), Herault (5
stations), Vaucluse (2 stations), and Corsica (25 stations) (see Table
I). Electrophoresis on horizontal starch gel revealed 28 loci. Introg
ression was quantified using three diagnostic protein loci : lactate d
ehydrogenase of the eye (LDH-5), serum transferrin (TF*) and fructose
biphosphatase of liver (FBP-1). The individuals identified as domest
icated fish on the basis of their genotype were discarded. Frequencies
at diagnostic loci, expected heterozygosity, the deviation from panmi
xia in each sample, and domestic introgression are given in Table II.
Heterozygote deficit was estimated using parameter f of WEIR and COCKH
ERAM (1984). Likewise, parameter 8 was used to assess whether the stru
cture of the different samples was statistically significant. The valu
es of these two parameters were tested by permutation using the GENETI
X 2.0 programme (BELKHIR et al., submitted). The populations analysed
can be classified according to their degree of introgression, which ra
nged from 0 to 77 %. Most introgressed populations displayed substanti
al and significant heterozygote deficit. Stocking is the most likely c
ause of these imbalances. However, this interpretation cannot be gener
alised to all the samples because the deficit did not increase with th
e severity of introgression. The results as a whole tend to show that
stocking has a genetic effect on natural populations (with changes in
their genotype, and imbalances in panmixia and linkages). The data als
o illustrate the weak effect of stocking on population densities. This
has already been reported by several authors. The various causes for
this lack of success in stocking (stocking techniques, learning proble
ms in the wild environment, domestication) are discussed. Introgressio
n-free Mediterranean populations generally occur at high altitudes and
they are practically monomorphic. The advantages of conserving geneti
cally pure populations with no polymorphism are discussed. Two solutio
ns that reconcile objectives as different as supporting trout populati
on densities and protecting biodiversity are examined :the creation of
local strains, which requires rigorous genetic management (CHEVASSUS,
1989) and the introduction of triploid individuals, which would resul
t in solely ecological interactions. Finally, the question of the comp
lete interruption of stocking in the whole area or in ''genetic sanctu
aries'' that have been identified as genetically original is discussed
. Other diagnostic markers distinguishing trout of the two origins hav
e been described recently. They provide information on introgression a
t levels other than that of proteins. The study of the mitochondrial g
enome gives data on the maternal origin of each individual and hence o
n introgression through the mother. Finally, the study of highly polym
orphic microsatellite markers will make it possible to distinguish bet
ween the natural and domesticated components of the populations of the
Atlantic basin, a zone in which there are no diagnostic allozymic loc
i for these two forms.