De. Sellmeyer et al., A high ratio of dietary animal to vegetable protein increases the rate of bone loss and the risk of fracture in postmenopausal women, AM J CLIN N, 73(1), 2001, pp. 118-122
Background: Different sources of dietary protein may have different effects
on bone metabolism. Animal foods provide predominantly acid precursors, wh
ereas protein in vegetable foods is accompanied by base precursors not foun
d in animal foods. Imbalance between dietary acid and base precursors leads
to a chronic net dietary acid load that may have adverse consequences on b
one.
Objective: We wanted to test the hypothesis that a high dietary ratio of an
imal to vegetable foods, quantified by protein content, increases bone loss
and the risk of fracture.
Design: This was a prospective cohort study with a mean (+/-SD) of 7.0 +/-
1.5 y of follow-up of 1035 community-dwelling white women aged >65 y. Prote
in intake was measured by using a food-frequency questionnaire and bone min
eral density was measured by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry.
Results: Bone mineral density was not significantly associated with the rat
io of animal to vegetable protein intake. Women with a high ratio had a hig
her rate of bone loss at the femoral neck than did those with a low ratio (
P = 0.02) and a greater risk of hip fracture (relative risk = 3.7, P = 0.04
). These associations were unaffected by adjustment for age, weight, estrog
en use, tobacco use, exercise, total calcium intake, and total protein inta
ke.
Conclusions: Elderly women with a high dietary ratio of animal to vegetable
protein intake have more rapid femoral neck bone loss and a greater risk o
f hip fracture than do those with a low ratio. This suggests that an increa
se in vegetable protein intake and a decrease in animal protein intake may
decrease bone loss and the risk of hip fracture. This possibility should be
confirmed in other prospective studies and tested in a randomized trial.