This study asks whether evidence that key macroeconomic time series are sta
tionary around broken trends is robust to using different criteria to deter
mine the lag length in the ADF regressions. When lag lengths are determined
using the Schwarz criterion or two different specific-to-general methods,
tests for unit roots in several series in the Nelson-Plosser (1982) data an
d in US postwar real GNP rnd weaker evidence against the unit root hypothes
is than either Perron (1989), who set the date for the break in the trend a
priori or Zivot and Andrews (1992), who determined the break date endogeno
usly.