Transgressed boundaries: Reflections on the problematics of culture and power in developing a collaborative relationship with teachers at an elementary school
Mt. Hayes et M. Kelly, Transgressed boundaries: Reflections on the problematics of culture and power in developing a collaborative relationship with teachers at an elementary school, CURRIC INQ, 30(4), 2000, pp. 451-472
In this article the author reflects upon his experiences trying to develop
a collaborative relationship with teachers in his role as a part-time scien
ce coordinator for their school. The author suggests that, despite his egal
itarian intentions, he inappropriately transgressed institutional boundarie
s that demarcate the world of university-based researchers and public schoo
l teachers. In crossing these boundaries particular power relations were en
acted that became an unstated yet powerful force in their relationship. Dra
wing upon a post-structuralist conception of power, the author interprets v
arious critical incidents in his interactions with teachers as at least par
tially constituted by power relations that were constantly negotiated and c
ontested in their relationship. Power is not viewed in structural terms of
dominance and subordinance, but as circulating throughout the relationship
and manifesting itself in various ways. Furthermore, these power relations
are rooted in the historical development of universities and schools and se
rve as a backdrop for their relationship. This hierarchical relationship wa
s inscribed into their relationship and manifested in various ways, ultimat
ely mitigating against the development of a collaborative relationship.