We examined the effect of age on breeding performance in male and female Me
rlins (Falco columbarius) from a natural population using a long-term data
set. In the analysis, we examined whether differences in chick hatch date a
nd brood size associated with parents of different ages arose due to select
ion of superior individuals (differential mortality hypothesis) or to chang
es within individuals over time (inadequate experience hypothesis). In addi
tion, we examined the effect of longevity on production of recruits and lif
etime reproductive success (LRS). In both sexes, breeding performance impro
ved with age. In females, this was mainly the result of disproportionate mo
rtality of inferior breeders, with less evidence to support performance cha
nges within individuals. Among males, changes in breeding performance with
age were largely the result of improvements within individuals early in the
ir life (between age 1 and 2+). Production of recruits was not dependent on
parental age at the time of breeding for either sex. Recruit production an
d LRS were both influenced by longevity. so that longer-lived birds produce
d more offspring over their lifetimes and thereby had a greater probability
of producing recruits. The differences between the sexes in terms of age-d
ependent breeding performance are likely a consequence of the differing rol
es the two parents play in reproduction. Male Merlins provide most of the f
ood for the pair and their young during the breeding season, and changes in
hunting skill with age may account for individual improvements in breeding
performance.