The intention of this paper is to analyze the view of architectural history
formulated in Geoffrey Scott's The Architecture of Humanism. While Scott's
views have commonly been placed in the tradition of empathy-based aestheti
cs, this paper will argue that most of Scott's arguments are dominantly mot
ivated more by aesthetic formalism. Scott's book is thus an important state
ment regarding the application of the formalist program in architectural hi
story. In order to present the full implications of this program, Scott's v
iews will be compared with the conception of art history exposed by Hans-Ge
org Gadamer in his Truth and Method.