M. Binzer et al., CLINICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF PATIENTS WITH MOTOR DISABILITY DUE TO CONVERSION DISORDER - A PROSPECTIVE CONTROL-GROUP STUDY, Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 63(1), 1997, pp. 83-88
Objectives-Previous studies have suggested associations between conver
sion and many different clinical characteristics. This study investiga
tes these findings in a prospective design including a control group.
Methods-Thirty consecutive patients with a recent onset of motor disab
ility due to a conversion disorder were compared with a control group
of patients with corresponding motor symptoms due to a definite organi
c lesion. Both groups had a similar duration of symptoms and a compara
ble age and sex profile and were assessed on a prospective basis. Back
ground information about previous somatic and psychiatric disease was
collected and all patients were assessed by means of a structured clin
ical interview linked to the diagnostic system DSM III-R, the Hamilton
rating depression scale, and a special life events inventory. Results
-The conversion group had a higher degree of psychopathology with 33%
of the patients fulfilling the criteria for psychiatric syndromes acco
rding to DSIM-III-R axis I, whereas 50% had axis II personality disord
ers compared with 10% and 17% respectively in the control group. Conve
rsion patients also had significantly higher scores according to the H
amilton rating depression scale. Although patients with known neurolog
ical disease were not included in the conversion group, a concomitant
somatic disorder was found in 33% of the patients and 50% complained o
f benign pain. The educational background in conversion patients was p
oor with only 13% having dropped out of high school compared with 67%
in the control group. Self reported global assessment of functioning a
ccording to the axis V on DSM IV was significantly lower in conversion
patients, who also registered significantly more negative life events
before the onset of symptoms than controls. Logistic regression analy
sis showed that low education, presence of a personality disorder, and
high Hamilton depression score were significantly associated with con
version disorder. Conclusion-The importance of several previously repo
rted predisposing and precipitating factors in conversion disorder is
confirmed. The results support the notion that conversion should be tr
eated as a symptom rather than a diagnosis and that efforts should be
made in diagnosing and treating possible underlying somatic and psychi
atric conditions.