Seed weight, seed germination, seedling survival, and juvenile/adult fitnes
s in chasmogamously (CH) and cleistogamously (CL) derived offspring of Oxal
is acetosella were compared during three growing seasons, to test hypothese
s of fitness differences between the offspring types accounting for the mai
ntenance of cleistogamy. In plots at three field sites, CH and CL seeds ori
ginating from all sites were sown to compare the performance of offspring g
rowing in their habitat of origin and offspring growing in new habitats. Se
eds were also sown in pots in a common garden, to test for effects of sibli
ng competition. Ct seeds had significantly lower germination than CH seeds
in the field, possibly because of lower mean seed weight due to later flowe
ring. Since the outcrossing rate in the CH flowers of O. acetosella is not
known, it is uncertain whether the lower CL germination is a consequence of
inbreeding depression. CH seeds had higher germination if sown at their ho
me sites than at new sites, white for CL seeds this made no difference; thi
s contradicts the local adaptation hypothesis for cleistogamy. No other fit
ness differences were found between the offspring types, and the findings d
id not support the sibling competition or local adaptation hypotheses. We s
uggest that the maintenance of the dimorphic reproductive system in O. acet
osella is not explained by offspring characteristics, but rather by the two
flowering phases complementing each other in maximizing annual seed produc
tion in the face of environmental variability. It is, therefore, important
to include temporal and spatial variation in studies of reproductive strate
gies.