Ka. Smith et al., Nutrient losses by surface run-off following the application of organic manures to arable land. 2. Phosphorus, ENVIR POLLU, 112(1), 2001, pp. 53-60
Phosphorus (P) surface run-off losses were studied following organic manure
applications to land, utilising a purpose-built facility on a sloping site
in Herefordshire under arable tillage. Different rates and timing of cattl
e slurry, farm yard manure (FYM) and inorganic nitrogen (N) and P fertilise
r were compared, over a 4-year period (1993-97). N losses from the same stu
dies are reported in a separate paper. The application of cattle FYM and, e
specially slurry, to the silty clay loam soil increased both particulate an
d soluble P loss in surface water flow. Losses via subsurface flow (30 cm i
nterflow) were consistently much lower than via surface water movement and
were generally unaffected by treatment. Increased application of slurry sol
ids increased all forms of P loss via surface run-off the results suggested
that a threshold for greatly increased risk of P losses via this route, as
for N, occurred at ca. 2.5-3.0 t/ha solids loading. This approximates to t
he 50 m(3)/ha application rate limit suggested for slurry within UK 'good a
gricultural practice'. The studies also provided circumstantial evidence of
the sealing of the soil surface by slurry solids as the major mechanism by
which polluting surface run-off may occur following slurry application on
susceptible soils. Losses of total and soluble P, recorded for each of the
4 years of experiments, reached a maximum of only up to 2 kg/ha total P (TP
), even after slurry applications initiating run-off. Whilst these losses a
re insignificant in agronomic terms, peak concentrations of P (up to 30,000
mug/l TP) in surface water during a run-off event, could be of considerabl
e concern in sensitive catchments. Losses of slurry P via surface run-off c
ould make a significant contribution to accelerated eutrophication on entry
to enclosed waters, particularly when combined with high concentrations of
NO3--N. Restricting slurry application rates to those consistent with good
agronomic practice, and within the limits specified in existing guidelines
on good agricultural practice, offers the simplest and most effective cont
rol measure against this potentially important source of diffuse pollution.
(C) 2001 Published by Elsevier Science Ltd.