S. Pruthi et al., SCIENTIFIC COMMUNITY AND PEER-REVIEW SYSTEM - A CASE-STUDY OF A CENTRAL GOVERNMENT FUNDING SCHEME IN INDIA, Journal of Scientific & Industrial Research, 56(7), 1997, pp. 398-407
An attempt has been made to evaluate soundness of a peer review system
operating for the funding scheme. An assessment of soundness has been
made on the basis of fairness, rationality, responsiveness, and accou
ntability. According to perception of scientists and engineers, the pe
er review system of the funding scheme appears to be fair, rational, a
ccountable, and responsive. However, there appears to be an urgent nee
d for improving the existing peer review system so as to maintain the
image associated with scheme in future.