In order to evaluate the PAH toxicity potential of our Soderberg cell emiss
ions, a first PAH HPLC/Fl method was developed in the early 1990's. A quali
ty control of PAH measurements, based on the B[a]P Eq. Index of homogeneous
, stable reference materials, was implemented to follow the pitches used in
the fabrication of anode pastes. This technique employed megabore columns
(4.6-mm o.d.) with twin fluorescence detectors. In the mid-1990's, this met
hod was upgraded to minibore columns in order to increase the accuracy. Dat
a for the same pitches was accumulated over a three-year period. This commu
nication compares the results from the two HPLC/Fl approaches including the
extraction procedures, the stability of the PAH extracts, the stability of
the equipment, the temporal resolution, the wavelengths used, etc., which
can affect the apparent PAH values. This new method has also been compared
with the results from other laboratories using different protocols and tech
niques including the presence of instrument specific interferences.