A. Holahan et V. Costenbader, A comparison of developmental gains for preschool children with disabilities in inclusive and self-contained classrooms, T EAR CHILD, 20(4), 2000, pp. 224-235
Two studies examined developmental outcomes associated with services in inc
lusive and self-contained preschool classrooms. In Study 1, the effects of
classroom inclusion on the developmental and social growth of preschool chi
ldren with disabilities were investigated on 15 pairs of children (N = 30)
matched for chronological age, gender, initial level of functioning, relate
d services received, and attendance schedules. Progress was measured with t
he Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Early Development-Revised using a pre-p
ost design. Results indicated that children functioning at a lower level of
social and emotional functioning performed equally well in inclusive and s
pecialized settings, while children functioning at a relatively higher leve
l performed better in inclusive settings than in specialized settings. In S
tudy 2, the relationships between developmental progress and the length of
the school day and the amount of related services received per week were in
vestigated on 66 participants. Children in full-day classrooms had greater
developmental delays but achieved higher rates of progress than their half-
day peers in the areas of social and emotional development and overall deve
lopment.