M. Couillard et P. Imbert, Speaking in the name of the people in 19th-century French Canada: Arguments and decontextualization, VOIX IMAGE, 26(1), 2000, pp. 109-127
The authors examine the argumentative and rhetorical processes- inanity arg
ument, perverse effect, etc.-that allowed 19th-century elites to speak on b
ehalf of the people, whose sovereignty was asserted. These struggles appear
ed throughout the continent, since at issue was the invention of nations in
a New World where ideological definitions were still unclear. For this rea
son, the analysis is placed in the context of liberal and traditionalist mo
vements opposing each other not only in French Canada, but also in Latin Am
erica.