S. Mirzaei et al., Scintimammography enhances negative predictive value of non-invasive pre-operative assessment of breast lesions, EUR J SUR O, 26(8), 2000, pp. 738-741
Aims: The aim of this study was to develop a criterion with a high negative
predictive value for the evaluation of breast lesions. We aimed to determi
ne the value of combining three non-invasive tests, mammography (MM), ultra
sonography (USS) and 99mTc-methoxyisobutylisonitrite (99mTc-MIBI) scintimam
mography (scinti-MM).
Methods: We included 94 consecutive patients with suspected lesions detecte
d by mammography or on physical examination. MM, USS and scinti-MM were per
formed no more than 4 weeks prior to excisional biopsy in all patients. We
then compared the biopsy results with a score calculated for each patient,
derived from the results of the three tests, which we termed 'mamma maligna
ncy index' (MMI).
Results: Each of the three exams yielded a score ranging from 0 to 2, with
0 representing ay almost certainly benign lesion, 1 an indeterminate findin
g and 2 a likely malignant lesion, and hence giving a total score ranging f
rom 0 to 6. The biopsy results showed that the lesions in 64 patients were
benign. Forty-nine (77%) of these patients had received an MMI score of 0 o
r 1. The negative predictive value for malignancy in patients with a score
less than 2 was 100%.
Conclusions: Since the smallest detected lesion was 9 mm in diameter, we co
nclude that MMI may be a highly useful diagnostic tool in the delineation o
f breast lesions greater than or equal to 1 cm which should not be routinel
y referred for biopsy but may be followed non-invasively. Although fine nee
dle aspiration has limitations, we would recommend it as a less invasive me
thod to evaluate suspected lesions smaller than 1 cm. (C) 2000 Harcourt Pub
lishers Ltd.