Antenatal provision of additional information about the role of students in the labour suite and their subsequent involvement in care: a randomised controlled trial
G. Mires et al., Antenatal provision of additional information about the role of students in the labour suite and their subsequent involvement in care: a randomised controlled trial, MED TEACH, 23(1), 2001, pp. 44-48
To determine whether the antenatal provision of additional information to p
regnant women about the roles of medical and midwifery students in the labo
ur suite increases their actual and theoretical involvement in care during
labour, 624 pregnant women booked for delivery at Ninewells Hospital and Me
dical School, Dundee were randomised at 34 weeks gestation to receive eithe
r a specifically produced information leaflet through the post on the roles
of medical and midwifery students in the labour suite, or no additional in
formation. Post delivery and following discharge, women were asked to compl
ete a questionnaire about people who were involved in their care during lab
our. There were no significant differences in a women's willingness (actual
or theoretical) to have medical or midwifery students involved in their ca
re between women who received additional information and those who did not.
Of those women who had a student present during labour, midwifery students
were significantly more involved in all care activities than medical stude
nts (p<0.01 for all activities), with the exception of vaginal examination.
Women who did not have a student present because one was not available, bu
t who indicated that they would have allowed a student to participate in th
eir care if one had been available, were significantly more likely to allow
a midwifery student to perform vaginal examinations, assist with delivery
and attend the baby than medical students (p<0.01 for all activities). They
would allow equal participation in other activities. For both groups of st
udents, these women appeared to be willing for significantly more active in
volvement in care than is happening in practice.