Trypanosome RNA editing is a massive processing of mRNA by U deletion and U
insertion, directed by trans-acting guide RNAs (gRNAs). A U deletion cycle
and a U insertion cycle have been reproduced in vitro using synthetic ATPa
se (A6) pre-mRNA and gRNA. Here we examine which gRNA features are importan
t for this U deletion. We find that, foremost, this editing depends critica
lly on the single-stranded character of a few gRNA and a few mRNA residues
abutting the anchor duplex, a feature not previously appreciated. That plus
any base-pairing sequence to tether the upstream mRNA are all the gRNA nee
ds to direct unexpectedly efficient in vitro U deletion, using either the p
urified editing complex or whole extract. In fact, our optimized gRNA const
ructs support faithful U deletion up to 100 times more efficiently than the
natural gRNA, and they can edit the majority of mRNA molecules. This is a
marked improvement of in vitro Il deletion, in which previous artificial gR
NAs were no more active than natural gRNA and the editing efficiencies were
at most a few percent. Furthermore, this editing is not stimulated by most
other previously noted gRNA features, including its potential ligation bri
dge, 3' OH moiety, any U residues in the tether, the conserved structure of
the central region, or proteins that normally bind these regions. Our data
also have implications about evolutionary forces active in RNA editing.