For many years now, subband and frequency-domain adaptive filtering techniq
ues have been proposed for the identification of high-order FIR systems. Cl
assical LMS-based algorithms are less attractive as their computational loa
d is higher and their convergence behaviour for coloured inputs is worse. S
ubband processing has many desirable properties. However, when used to impl
ement adaptive filters, various effects (such as residual errors and slow c
onvergence due to aliasing) occur and reduce performance. On the other hand
, it is known that frequency-domain adaptive filters do not suffer from the
se problems despite being (nearly) equivalent to subband adaptive filters,
be it with "poor" filter banks (modulated sine frequency responses). In thi
s paper the operation of the frequency-domain techniques are unravelled and
explained in the "subband jargon" and among other things it will be shown
how aliasing is compensated for in the frequency-domain approach. This pape
r aims at generalising frequency-domain aliasing-compensation techniques to
subband adaptive systems. Further, some design criteria for subband adapti
ve systems are formulated. Three realisation conditions and an alternative
adaptation scheme will be proposed. Standard subband adaptive filters canno
t fulfil all conditions, whereas for frequency-domain-based algorithms the
design criteria are met. (C) 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
.