Ka. Sinnott et al., Factors associated with thoracic spinal cord injury, lesion level and rotator cuff disorders, SPINAL CORD, 38(12), 2000, pp. 748-753
Background: The study was concerned with the secondary functional compromis
e persons with long-term paraplegia contend with, that has been shown to be
associated with wheelchair use. Of particular interest was the relationshi
p between the level of thoracic spinal cord injury (SCI) and factors predis
posing to rotator cuff disorders (RCD), one of the most common upper extrem
ity musculoskeletal complications linked with long-term SCI. Disorders of t
hese peri-articular structures have previously been associated with impaire
d trunk postural control and abnormal muscle strength ratios in both able-b
odied groups and in paraplegic athletes. Despite their neurologically intac
t shoulder joint musculature, high-level and low-level paraplegics have dif
ferent degrees of trunk and pelvic stability available to them during activ
ities of daily living (ADL). This fundamental functional anatomical differe
nce between high-level and low-level paraplegics had not previously been re
lated to the diagnosis of RCD in a non-athletic long-term paraplegic popula
tion.
Methods: A descriptive cross sectional study was undertaken to demonstrate
the differences in the prevalence of clinically diagnosed RCD in a high-lev
el (n = 22) and a low-level (n = 20) group of persons with long-term parapl
egia. Any perceived differences were then related to the functional anatomi
cal variations between the two groups. Inferences were made based on factor
s predisposing to RCD known to exist among both able-bodied and paraplegic
athletes. The 42 subjects completed the Wheelchair User's Shoulder Pain Ind
ex (WUSPI) to establish the presence or absence of shoulder pain and the Mu
sculoskeletal Function Assessment (MFA) instrument to determine differences
in functional ability and perceived degree of difficulty within five categ
ories of ADL. Each participant underwent a clinical examination using valid
ated provocative clinical tests and isometric muscle strength ratio testing
.
Results: There was a higher prevalence of RCD in the high-level group (P=0.
009) which correlated with decreased trunk control (P = 0.009). Differences
in ability to perform functional tasks were not shown to be greater in the
high-level group, although there was a higher degree of perceived difficul
ty in ADL. Muscle strength imbalances between the shoulder adductors and ab
ductors were shown to be greater in the high-level group.
Conclusions: The results of this study suggest that the functional anatomic
al differences that exist within paraplegia contribute to the propensity of
high-level paraplegic persons to suffer from RCD. These findings send a cl
ear message to service-providers that greater acknowledgement of the differ
ences in trunk postural control specific to the level of thoracic SCI is re
quired. This may have implications for the prescription of wheelchairs, ass
istive devices and instruction for alternative ADL techniques to this speci
fic population.