Local tumor control and cosmetic outcome following breast-conserving surgery and radiation up to a total dose of 56 Gy without boost in breast cancerpatients
A. Bayerl et al., Local tumor control and cosmetic outcome following breast-conserving surgery and radiation up to a total dose of 56 Gy without boost in breast cancerpatients, STRAH ONKOL, 177(1), 2001, pp. 25-32
Purpose: To evaluate overall survival, local tumor control and cosmetic out
come after breast-conserving surgery followed by radiotherapy without, boos
t irradiation.
Patients end Methods: In a retrospective study 270 breast cancer patients w
ere treated with breast conserving surgery combined with a homogenous radia
tion of the tumor bearing breast up to a total dose of 56 Gy without Local
boost irradiation. Mean follow-up was 48 months. Local tumor control, side
effects, cosmetic results and contentment with treatment were assessed usin
g physical examinations and interviews based on a standardized questionnair
e.
Results: Cause-specific survival at 5 years after treatment was 88.3%, actu
arial disease-free survival at 5 years was 76.1%. Within 23 to 78 months af
ter treatment 12 patients suffered from ipsilateral breast recurrence. The
actuarial freedom from local recurrence (single tumor manifestation) was 96
.8% at 5 years after treatment, 89% at 10 years. The occurrence of Local fa
ilures was not significantly correlated to tumor size, margins, grading, no
dal status, age or lymphangiosis. 15.6% of the patients developed distant m
etastases. In all patients treatment was performed without interruption. Si
de effects were predominantly of mild degree, no severe side effects were d
etected. 73% of physicians and 81% of patients scored their cosmetic outcom
e as excellent or good. 93% of patients would again decide in favor of this
procedure. Whereas use of adjuvant chemotherapy as well as subcutaneous re
construction of breast tissue did not significantly affect breast cosmesis,
analysis demonstrated impaired cosmetic results related to a Larger breast
size.
Conclusion: The data of this study show that tumor control achieved by brea
st conserving surgery in combination with a radiation technique up to a tot
al dose of 56 Gy which omits boost irradiation is within the range of Liter
ature data. Side effects of the therapy were tolerable. The treatment displ
ayed a good compatibility with tolerable side effects and good cosmetic res
ults.