Aj. Muster et al., The left-sided aortic arch in humans, viewed as the end-result of natural selection during vertebrate evolution, CARD YOUNG, 11(1), 2001, pp. 111-122
Rt some point during vertebrate evolution from species dwelling in water to
living on land, the ancestral double or right aortic arches became single
and left-sided in mammals, including humans, as the result of synchronous d
evelopments in cardiovascular and respiratory embryogenesis. Since left-sid
ed aortic arches are unique to mammals, hemodynamics related to the placent
a, specifically the requirement for a large arterial duct connecting to the
descending aorta, may have led to switching from the right-sided to the le
ft-sided arch. Additionally, development of a trilobar right lung and its b
ronchial tree, also unique to mammalian evolution, restricted the space abo
ve the high eparterial bronchus to a single large vessel. Consequently, mam
mals that mutated to the left-sided aortic arch avoided respiratory, digest
ive or circulatory problems that are often associated with an isolated righ
t-sided aortic arch - something which could be considered a successful mist
ake. Due to natural selection, and survival of the fittest, the left-sided
arch became the norm ill mammals.
In congenital cardiac malformations where a large arterial duct is not mand
atory in fetal life, as in Fallot's tetralogy or common arterial trunk, a r
ight-sided aortic arch continues to occur, perhaps as an atavistic reversio
n to the anatomy seen in ancestral vertebrates.