Optimal duration of preoperative therapy in unilateral and nonmetastatic Wilms' tumor in children older than 6 months: Results of the ninth International Society of Pediatric Oncology Wilms' tumor trial and study
Mf. Tournade et al., Optimal duration of preoperative therapy in unilateral and nonmetastatic Wilms' tumor in children older than 6 months: Results of the ninth International Society of Pediatric Oncology Wilms' tumor trial and study, J CL ONCOL, 19(2), 2001, pp. 488-500
Purpose: To determine the optimal duration of preoperative chemotherapy to
further increase the proportion of stage I tumors by comparison of two regi
mens in the treatment of patients older than 6 months who have unilateral W
ilms' tumor.
Patients and Methods: Eligible patients (n = 382) initially received four w
eekly doses of vincristine (VCR) and two courses of actinomycin D (AMD) and
were randomized either to be operated on (4-week group [n = 193]) or to re
ceive 4 more weeks of the same chemotherapy regimen (8-week group [n = 189]
). The assessment criterion was the observed percentage of stage I tumors.
After surgery, patients were assigned according to tumor stage and histolog
y to four different treatment groups: stage I and favorable histology (n =
5) were to have no further treatment (NFT); stage I and standard histology
or anaplasia (n = 244), VCR and AMD for 17 weeks (AV); stages II and III an
d favorable or standard histology, VCR, AMD, and an anthracycline for 27 we
eks (AVE) with no abdominal radiotherapy for stage II N0 disease (n = 75) o
r with a 15-Gy dose of abdominal irradiation (RTH) in case of stages IIN1 a
nd III (n = 56). Anaplastic tumors staged higher than I or clear-cell sarco
ma of the kidney (14), AMD, VCR, an anthracycline, and ifosfamide for 36 we
eks (DEVI).
Results: No advantage wets found in favor of prolonged preoperative treatme
nt. The percentages obtained for the 4-week and the 8-week groups, respecti
vely, were as follows: stage I, 64% versus 62%; intraoperative tumor ruptur
e rate, 1% versus 3%; 2-year EFS, 84% versus 83%; and 5-year OS, 92% versus
87%. Two-year EFS and 5-year OS rates, respectively, of the different trea
tment groups were as follows: NFT, 100% for both EFS and OS; AV, 88% and 93
%; AVE, 84% and 88%; AM RTH, 71% and 85%; and DM, 71% and 71%. The rate of
abdominal recurrences in stage II NO nonirradiated patients was 6.6%.
Conclusion: The 4-week schedule pre-nephrectomy chemotherapy regimen should
be considered the standard treatment. Clinical trials should continue to i
mprove the cure rate of high-risk patients and the quality of life of child
ren with ct more favorable prognosis. J Clin Oncol 19:488-500. (C) 9001 by
American Society of Clinical Oncology.