L. Kolbe et al., Objective bioengineering methods to assess the effects of moisturizers on xerotic leg skin of elderly people, J DERM TR, 11(4), 2000, pp. 241-245
BACKGROUND: Dry, itchy, scaly skin is a common and distressing problem for
elderly people. The regression method is commonly employed to compare the e
fficacy of moisturizers. However, this method relies solely on clinical est
imates of scale removal and provides no information on the structural and f
unctional changes of the stratum corneum.
METHODS: We compared a commercial 15% glycolic acid lotion (NeoStrata) with
a traditional water in oil emulsion containing a mixture of lanolin alcoho
ls. mineral oil, ana petrolatum (Eucerin cream). These were applied twice d
aily for 6 weeks to the xerotic legs of elderly women. A variety of methods
were used to assess the effects on the horny layer barrier.
RESULTS: The time to induce burning by chloroform:methanol was decreased by
NeoStrata and increased by Eucerin. Transepidermal water loss increased af
ter NeoStrata treatment and decreased after Eucerin treatment. The stratum
corneum was more resistant to NaOH erosions with Eucerin but remained uncha
nged with NeoStrata. Dimethyl sulfoxide whealing decreased with Eucerin but
was unchanged with NeoStrata, The inflammatory reaction to sodium lauryl s
ulfate was diminished by Eucerin and increased by NeoStrata.
CONCLUSION: Both treatments were equally effective in smoothing the surface
. However, the glycolic acid lotion weakened the stratum corneum barrier in
contrast with Eucerin, which enhanced it.