He. Tillett et al., External quality assessment of microbial counts from water: To score or not to score for proficiency, J CHART I W, 14(4), 2000, pp. 304-308
Citations number
7
Categorie Soggetti
Environment/Ecology
Journal title
JOURNAL OF THE CHARTERED INSTITUTION OF WATER AND ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
Scoring schemes were first introduced in water-chemistry inter-laboratory p
roficiency tests. Such scoring does not behave in a comparable manner when
applied to microbiology external quality assessment. Conventional scores ca
n become a lottery. This poses a challenge to (a) find helpful statistical
methods which will look beyond this natural variation and (b) attempt to id
entify any poor performance by the participants. The aim is to provide usef
ul management tools.
In the Public Health Laboratory Service, water external quality assessment
scheme participants have detected methodology problems. Formal analyses are
carried out on cumulated results in two stages, first demonstrating whethe
r there is any systematic difference between laboratories of microbiologica
l as well as statistical significance and only then allocating participants
to categories of acceptable, or poor, performance. The scheme has been ope
rating for several years and performance improvements are evident.