Msy. Lee, PHYLOGENETIC-RELATIONSHIPS AMONG AUSTRALIAN ELAPID SNAKES - THE SOFT ANATOMICAL DATA RECONSIDERED, Herpetological journal, 7(3), 1997, pp. 93-102
On the basis of an extensive set of visceral and scale characters, Wal
lach (1985) proposed a detailed phylogenetic scheme for all the Austra
lian elapids, down to species level. The shortest tree found in that a
nalysis is here shown to contain 592 steps. However, a re-analysis of
the same data using PAUP 3.1.1 reveals that there are 258 most parsimo
nious trees, each with only 578 steps. The strict consensus of these t
rees is much less resolved than Wallach's tree, and has a different to
pology. For example, Echiopsis is most closely related to Suta fasciat
a rather than to the Notechis lineage, and Demansia is more closely re
lated to advanced elapids (such as the Notechis lineage) than to Oxyur
anus and Pseudonaja. Many of the larger (suprageneric) groupings propo
sed by Wallach are paraphyletic in the PAUP consensus tree. Almost all
the groupings in this tree, however, can be collapsed with the additi
on of a single extra step. There are more than 32 000 cladograms at 57
9 steps, one step longer than the 258 most parsimonious cladograms. A
strict consensus tree of cladograms 578 and 579 steps long is almost c
ompletely unresolved. The visceral and external morphological traits,
therefore, are not as phylogenetically informative as previously propo
sed, at least with respect to the Australian elapid radiation. These t
ypes of characters might not be very phylogenetically informative at h
igher (intergeneric) levels, although much more data are required to t
est this hypothesis.