Objective: Energy restriction reduces the incidence of malignant tumors in
experimental animals, but evidence for a similar effect in humans is lackin
g. To test the hypothesis in humans, we investigated cancer incidence among
patients with anorexia nervosa, who have had an extremely low intake of ca
lories for prolonged periods of their lives.
Methods: Patients with anorexia nervosa (2151 women and 186 men) during 197
0-1993 were identified in the population-based Danish Psychiatric Case Regi
ster and the National Registry of Patients. The cohort was linked to the Da
nish Cancer Registry, and cancer incidence among cohort members was compare
d with that of the general population.
Results: The overall cancer incidence among women with anorexia nervosa was
reduced by a factor of 0.80 (95% confidence interval 0.52-1.18) below that
of the general population on the basis of 25 observed and 31.4 expected ca
ses. Among men, two cases of cancer were observed, both confined to the bra
in, whereas 0.2 cases were expected.
Conclusions: The finding of a slight reduction in cancer risk among women w
ith anorexia nervosa may support the theory that a low-energy diet may decr
ease tumor development in humans. However, longer follow-up and control for
confounding factors are needed to obtain more convincing evidence.