A new solution to Cartwright's paradox

Citation
M. Garcia-carpintero, A new solution to Cartwright's paradox, CRITICA, 32(95), 2000, pp. 47-70
Citations number
17
Categorie Soggetti
Philosiphy
Journal title
CRITICA-REVISTA HISPANOAMERICANA DE FILOSOFIA
ISSN journal
00111503 → ACNP
Volume
32
Issue
95
Year of publication
2000
Pages
47 - 70
Database
ISI
SICI code
0011-1503(200008)32:95<47:ANSTCP>2.0.ZU;2-K
Abstract
The paper offers a new solution to a paradox introduced by Richard Cartwrig ht and discussed by Kaplan. The paradox is, in a nutshell, as follows. Supp ose that we name with '(1)' the statement 'the last word of (1) is obscene, ' and with '(2)' the statement 'the last word of (1) is obscene.' It seems that, although under these stipulations (1) = (2), (2) has a modal property which (1) lacks, to wit: it can be turned into a truth by quoting its last word. But this seems to contradict Leibniz' Law. In offering a solution wh ich differs somehow from the one favored by Kaplan, I put to use proposals on the semantics of indexicals and proper names I have defended in previous works. To the extent that the solution improves on previous ones, it provi des partial confirmation for the semantic proposals it relies.