The paper focuses on the stability analysis of a certain class of catc
h- and effort-controlled discrete stock - production models for optima
l management of exploited populations, which were used as official met
hods for Cape hake assessments in the International Commission for the
Southeast Atlantic Fishery (ICSEAF) during 1988 - 1990, and are still
used for forecasting TACs of this species and other commercially fish
ed stocks. Ln spite of the formal approach used, the problem is of the
utmost practical importance as instability of a model raises the inac
curacy of the resultant estimates, providing also failures at the stag
e of the model fitting and total allowable catch (TAG) forecasting. So
, clarification of the stability conditions of stock - production mode
ls enables their more deliberate and effective use in management of ma
rine living resources. The effort-controlled models exhibit higher sta
bility as compared with the catch-controlled ones: the fishing effort
acts as a recovering force which suppresses the perturbations initiate
d in the model by the inevitable errors in estimating the initial popu
lation level. Therefore, the optimal management strategies and the TAC
forecasts derived from the effort-controlled models are less risky th
an those obtained with the use of the catch-controlled ones.