Jr. Difranza et al., What is the potential cost-effectiveness of enforcing a prohibition on thesale of tobacco to minors?, PREV MED, 32(2), 2001, pp. 168-174
Background, Enforcement programs to halt the sale of tobacco to youths have
been implemented across the United States. The potential cost-effectivenes
s of enforcement mas evaluated under a range of assumptions regarding cost
and impact.
Methods. An enforcement model was constructed incorporating quarterly inspe
ctions of all tobacco vendors. The cost of discounted years of life saved w
as calculated using reported values regarding cost and a range of assumptio
ns regarding the impact on youth tobacco use.
Results. Inspecting an estimated 543,000 tobacco outlets would cost up to $
190 million annually Costs range from $44 to $8,200 per year of life saved
depending on the discount rate and assumptions regarding cost, and efficacy
To compete in cost-effectiveness with implementing smoking cessation guide
lines, enforcement would hare to produce a 5% reduction in adolescent smoki
ng at a cost of no more than $250 per vendor.
Conclusion. At this level of cost and effectiveness an enforcement program
could save 10 times as many Lives as the same amount spent on mammography o
r screening for colorectal carcinoma. A one-cent per pack cigarette tax cou
ld fully fund enforcement. Enforcement of tobacco sales laws deserves furth
er study as one component of a multifaceted approach to tobacco use prevent
ion. (C) 2001 American Health Foundation and Academic Press.