Proliferation is controlled by a network of mitogenic and growth inhibitory
factors. Transforming growth factor-beta (1) (TGF-beta (1)) and activin A
are the most important growth inhibitors of benign follicular epithelial ce
lls of the human thyroid. The effects of these substances on malignant prim
ary thyrocytes are not known. We have examined the growth regulatory effect
s of activin A and TGF-beta (1) in primary cultures derived from four papil
lary cancers, two follicular thyroid cancers, and three benign thyroid tiss
ues. Malignant cells demonstrated resistance to activin and TGF-beta (1) or
reversal to a weak but significant mitogenic effect (p < 0.001). We also e
valuated the activin receptor transcription pattern. Isoforms alk4-1, 4-2,
and 4-3 were found in benign (n = 12) and malignant (n = 22) tissues. Two s
ubtypes of type I and type II activin receptors were demonstrated. Semiquan
titative reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) demonstra
ted a significant threefold downregulation of alk4-1 receptors in papillary
(n = 25) and follicular (n = 18) thyroid cancers as compared to normal thy
roids (n = 12) (p <0.001). To our knowledge these are the first data to dem
onstrate reversal of activin and TGF-beta (1) effects in thyroid malignancy
and to demonstrate changes of the type Ib activin receptor expression in t
hyroid malignancy.