Tm. Frayling et al., beta-cell genes and diabetes - Molecular and clinical characterization of mutations in transcription factors, DIABETES, 50, 2001, pp. S94-S100
beta -Cell transcription factor genes are important in the pathophysiology
of the beta -cell, with mutations in hepatocyte nuclear factor (HNF)-1 alph
a, HNF-4 alpha, insulin promoter factor (IPF)-1, HNF-1 beta, and NeuroD1/BE
TA2, all resulting in early-onset type 2 diabetes. We assessed the relative
contribution of these genes to early-onset type 2 diabetes using linkage a
nd sequencing analysis in a cohort of 101 families (95% U.K. Caucasian). Th
e relative distribution of the 90 families fitting maturity-onset diabetes
of the young (MODY) criteria was 63% HNF-1 alpha, 2% HNF-4 alpha, 0% IPF-1,
1% HNF-1 beta, 0% NeuroD1/ BETA2, and 20% glucokinase. We report the molec
ular genetic and clinical characteristics of these patients including 29 ne
w families and 8 novel HNF-1 alpha gene mutations. Mutations in the transac
tivation domain are more likely to be protein truncating rather than result
in amino acid substitutions, suggesting that a relatively severe disruptio
n of this domain is necessary to result in diabetes. Mutations in the diffe
rent transcription factors result in clinical heterogeneity. IPF-1 mutation
s are associated with a higher age at diagnosis (42.7 years) than HNF-1 alp
ha (20.4 years), HNF-1 beta (24.2 years), or HNF-4 alpha (26.3 years) gene
mutations. Subjects with HNF-1 beta mutations, in contrast to the other tra
nscription factors, frequently present with renal disease. A comparison of
age at diagnosis between subjects with different types and locations of HNF
-1 alpha mutations did not reveal genotype-phenotype correlations. In concl
usion, mutations in transcription factors expressed in the beta -cellw are
the major cause of MODY, and the phenotype clearly varies with the gene tha
t is mutated. There is little evidence to indicate that different mutations
within the same gene have different phenotypes.