The first guideline statement of the Year 2000 edition of Nutrition and You
r Health: Dietary Guidelines for Americans is "Aim for a healthy weight." T
he purpose of this paper is to describe the evolution of the weight guideli
ne and discuss some issues related to it. We reviewed current and previous
editions of the Dietary Guidelines and the corresponding advisory committee
reports. The weight guideline has evolved over the years into one that is
complex and touches on a wide range of issues. The 2000 edition emphasizes
weight loss more than previous editions. Unlike the other guidelines in the
Dietary Guidelines, the weight guideline has a health outcome, a "healthy"
weight, rather than a behavioral outcome as its goal. Also unlike the othe
r guidelines, the weight guideline has become more medically oriented over
time. The concept of healthy weight in the guidelines includes aspects of b
ody composition, fat distribution and weight-related health conditions, it
may be difficult for the public and even for health care providers to inter
pret some of the concepts included in the weight guideline. Issues related
to the appropriate management of weight can be complex and may require a he
alth care provider as a resource for interpretation. Rather than try to inc
orporate further clinical decision-making and weight loss guidance within t
he weight guideline, it may be more appropriate to refer the reader to a he
alth care provider for guidance, as was done in previous editions.