Polyvalent envelope glycoprotein vaccine elicits a broader neutralizing antibody response but is unable to provide sterilizing protection against heterologous Simian/human immunodeficiency virus infection in pigtailed macaques
Mw. Cho et al., Polyvalent envelope glycoprotein vaccine elicits a broader neutralizing antibody response but is unable to provide sterilizing protection against heterologous Simian/human immunodeficiency virus infection in pigtailed macaques, J VIROLOGY, 75(5), 2001, pp. 2224-2234
The great difficulty in eliciting broadly cross-reactive neutralizing antib
odies (NAbs) against human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-l) isolates h
as been attributed to several intrinsic properties of their viral envelope
glycoprotein, including its complex quaternary structure, extensive glycosy
lation, and marked genetic variability. Most previously evaluated vaccine c
andidates have utilized envelope glycoprotein from a single virus isolate.
Here we compare the breadth of NAb and protective immune response following
vaccination of pigtailed macaques with envelope protein(s) derived from ei
ther single or multiple viral isolates. Animals were challenged with Simian
/human immunodeficiency virus strain DH12 (SHTVDH12) following priming with
recombinant vaccinia virus(es) expressing gp160(s) and boosting with gp120
protein(s) from (1) LAI, RIF, 89.6, ADS, and Bal (Polyvalent); (ii) LAI, R
F, 89.6, AD8, Bal, and DH12 (Polyvalent-DH12); (iii) 89.6 (Monovalent-89.6)
; and (iv) DH12 (Monovalent-DH12). Animals in the two polyvalent vaccine gr
oups developed NAbs against more HIV-1 isolates than those in the two monov
alent vaccine groups (P = 0.0054). However, the increased breadth of respon
se was directed almost entirely against the vaccine strains. Resistance to
SHIVDH12 strongly correlated with the level of NAbs directed against the vi
rus on the day of challenge (P = 0.0008). Accordingly, the animals in the M
onovalent-DH12 and Polyvalent-DH12 vaccine groups were more resistant to th
e SHIVDH12 challenge than the macaques immunized with preparations lacking
a DH12 component (viz. Polyvalent and Monovalent-89.6) (P = 0.039). Despite
the absence of any detectable NAb, animals in the Polyvalent vaccine group
, but not those immunized with Monovalent-89.6, exhibited markedly lower le
vels of plasma virus than those in the control group, suggesting a superior
cell-mediated immune response induced by the polyvalent vaccine.