Tm. O'Connor et al., Aggressive management leads to improved survival in patients with small cell lung carcinoma, IRISH J MED, 169(3), 2000, pp. 204-207
Background Small cell lung carcinoma (SCLC) accounts for 17-25% of ail case
s of lung cancer, and remains the most lethal form of this disease.
Aims We sought to determine whether an aggressive treatment policy led to a
n increase in median survival in patients with SCLC in our institution.
Methods From 1985 to 1993, patients with SCLC were often treated conservati
vely on the basis of advanced age or poor performance status. From 1993 to
1998, a more aggressive management policy was adopted. All patients were tr
eated with chemotherapy. Radiotherapy was administered, where appropriate,
following the completion of chemotherapy. The medical records of 66 patient
s were analysed and clinical outcomes were compared.
Results Median survival in the 1993-98 group (332 days) was significantly b
etter compared to the 1985-93 group (194 days) (p = 0.02). In patients with
limited disease, median survival in the 1993-98 group (489 days) was also
significantly better compared to the 1985-93 group (254 days) (p = 0.04). T
he difference in median survival in extensive disease was not significant (
p = 0.09).
Conclusions The presented data suggest that appropriate aggressive manageme
nt of patients with SCLC leads to a significant increase in median survival
. This survival benefit is most apparent in patients with limited disease.