Because habitat loss is a leading cause of extinction, it is important to i
dentify what kind of species is most vulnerable. Here, I use algebraic and
graphical techniques to study metacommunity models of weak competition or l
ocally facultative mutualism in which species may coexist within patches. B
ecause a competition-colonization tradeoff is not required for regional coe
xistence of competitors, poor competitors are often regionally rare and mos
t prone to extinction, in contrast to results from previous models of stron
gly competitive metapopulations. Metacommunities of mutualists can suffer t
he abrupt extinction of both species as habitat destruction is increased. T
hese highlight the importance of identifying the mechanisms by which specie
s coexist to predict their response to habitat loss.