N. Cowan et al., THERE ARE 2 WORD-LENGTH EFFECTS IN VERBAL SHORT-TERM-MEMORY - OPPOSEDEFFECTS OF DURATION AND COMPLEXITY, Psychological science, 8(4), 1997, pp. 290-295
In the word-length effect (WLE), lists of shorter words are better rec
alled than lists of longer words. This effect is fundamental to decay-
based theories of verbal short-term memory,: such as the phonological
loop theory (Baddeley, 1986). The WLE has been attributed to the time
taken to articulate, words, not their structure, a critical point in t
he debate between decay and interference theories. However, word durat
ion and complexity have previously been confounded. In this article, M
le show that the traditional WLE comprises two opposed effects: an adv
antage for words spoken more quickly (short words in terms of duration
) and an advantage for words with more elements (long words in terms o
f complexity). We also report two interactions: a disadvantage for a m
idlist change in duration and an advantage for a midlist change in com
plexity. These results contradict simple decay-based theories and esta
blish the importance of interference in short term memory. We discuss
whether decay is also required.