C. Ferrerovacher et al., EVALUATION OF THE ABX-COBAS-VEGA-AUTOMATED-HEMATOLOGY-ANALYZER AND COMPARISON WITH THE COULTER-STKS, HEM CELL TH, 39(3), 1997, pp. 149-158
An evaluation of the new automated hematology analyzer was performed i
n comparison with the Coulter STKS on 1,694 blood samples coming from
the different departments of Nice University Hospital. The Cobas Vega
showed very satisfactory results in terms of repeatability, reproducib
ility and linearity. Correlation with the STKS was excellent with the
exception of the following parameters: red blood cell distribution ind
ex and the absolute values for eosinophils and basophils. Two qualitie
s were particularly appreciable: absence of leukocyte carryover, and s
tability of the complete blood count and leukocyte differential count
over a long period. Analysis of qualitative flags showed that the over
all blood smear review rate was 47% for the Cobas Vega, not forgetting
that optical microscopy detects 37% of all abnormalities. The STKS's
review rate was 49.5%. Flags commonly concerned the granulocytic linea
ge, 61% for the STKS and 48% for the Vega, with a false positive rate
of 43.4% for the STKS compared with 22% for the Vega. The opposite phe
nomenon was observed with the flag for atypical lymphocytes which repr
esented 11% of flags for the STKS and 25.6% for the Vega, with a false
positive rate of 25.5% for the STKS and 34% for the Cobas Vega. This
may be explained by the fact that lymphocyte abnormalities sometimes g
enerated ''granulocytic'' flags on the STKS. Studies of the false nega
tive rate carried out using light microscopy on 505 blood samples with
out flags on either system, detected the presence of a slight myelemia
, and a few hyperbasophilic lymphocytes or plasmocytes in 18.6% of all
cases. Finally, the Cobas Vega's practicality was greatly appreciated
and there was no trouble with breakdowns throughout the whole period
of its use.