De. Kinnison et al., MODEL STUDY OF ATMOSPHERIC TRANSPORT USING CARBON-14 AND STRONTIUM-90AS INERT TRACERS, JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-ATMOSPHERES, 99(D10), 1994, pp. 20647-20664
The observed excess carbon 14 in the atmosphere from 1963 to 1970 prov
ides unique, but limited, data up to an altitude of about 35 km for te
sting the air motions calculated by 11 multidimensional atmospheric mo
dels. Strontium 90 measurements in the atmosphere from 1964 to mid-196
7 provide data that have more latitude coverage than those of carbon 1
4 and are useful for testing combined models of air motions and aeroso
l settling. Model calculations for carbon 14 begin at October 1963, 9
months after the conclusion of the nuclear bomb tests; the initial con
ditions for the calculations are derived by three methods, each of whi
ch agrees fairly well with measured carbon 14 in October 1963 and each
of which has widely different values in regions of the stratosphere w
here there were no carbon 14 measurements. The model results are compa
red to the stratospheric measurements, not as if the observed data wer
e absolute standards, but in an effort to obtain new insight about the
models and about the atmosphere. The measured carbon 14 vertical prof
iles at 31 degrees N are qualitatively different from all of the model
s; the measured vertical profiles show a maximum mixing ratio in the a
ltitude range of 20 to 25 km from October 1963 through July 1966, but
all modeled profiles show mixing ratio maxima that increase in altitud
e from 20 km in October 1963 to greater than 40 km by April 1966. Both
carbon 14 and strontium 90 data indicate that the models differ subst
antially among themselves with respect to stratosphere-troposphere exc
hange rate, but the modeled carbon 14 stratospheric residence times in
dicate that differences among the models are small with respect to tra
nsport rate between the middle stratosphere and the lower stratosphere
. Strontium 90 data indicate that aerosol settling is important up to
at least 35 km altitude. Relative to the measurements, about three qua
rters of the models transport carbon 14 from the lower stratosphere to
the troposphere too rapidly, and all models with all three sets of in
itial conditions appear to sweep carbon 14 out of the midstratosphere
(above 28 km) much more slowly than was observed from 1963 to 1970. At
mospheric dynamicists should seriously consider what the carbon 14 mea
surements imply with respect to advection in the midstratosphere.