N. Arab-moghaddam et M. Senechal, Orthographic and phonological processing skills in reading and spelling inPersian/English bilinguals, INT J BEHAV, 25(2), 2001, pp. 140-147
The concurrent development of reading and spelling in English and Persian w
ere examined in a sample of bilingual children. The objective was to compar
e how phonological and orthographic processing skills contribute to reading
and spelling for two alphabetic languages that differ drastically. English
orthography is characterised by both polyphony (i.e., a grapheme represent
ing more than one phoneme) and polygraphy (i.e., a phoneme represented by m
ore than one grapheme) which results in a complex script to read and write.
In contrast, vowelised-Persian orthography is characterised by polygraphy
only, which results in a simple script to read but more complex to write. F
ifty-five Iranian children in grades 2 and 3, who had lived in English-spea
king Canada for an average of 4 years, were tested on word reading and spel
ling in English and Persian. We found that the predictors of reading perfor
mance were similar across languages: Phonological and orthographic processi
ng skills each predicted unique variance in word reading in English and in
Persian once we had controlled for grade level, vocabulary, and reading exp
erience. As expected, the predictors of spelling performance differed acros
s language: Spelling in English was predicted similarly by phonological and
orthographic processing skills, whereas spelling in Persian was predicted
by orthographic processing skills only. It is possible that the nature of t
he Persian orthography encourages children to adopt different strategies wh
en reading and spelling words. Spelling Persian words might be particularly
conducive to using an analytic strategy which, in turn, promotes the devel
opment of and reliance on orthographic skills.