Cathepsin K (EC 3.4.22.38), a cysteine protease of the papain superfamily,
is predominantly expressed in osteoclasts and has been postulated as a targ
et for the treatment of osteoporosis. Crystallographic and structure-activi
ty studies on a series of acyclic ketone-based inhibitors of cathepsin K ha
ve led to the design and identification of two series of cyclic ketone inhi
bitors. The mode of binding for four of these cyclic and acyclic inhibitors
to cathepsin K is discussed and compared. All of the structures are consis
tent with addition of the active site thiol to the ketone of the inhibitors
with the formation of a hemithioketal. Cocrystallization of the C-3 diaste
reomeric 3-amidotetrahydrofuran-4-one analogue 16 with cathepsin K showed t
he inhibitor to occupy the unprimed side of the active site with the 3S dia
stereomer preferred. This C-3 stereochemical preference is in contrast to t
he X-ray cocrystal structures of the 3-amidopyrrolidin-4-one inhibitors 29
and 33 which show these inhibitors to prefer binding of the 3R diastereomer
. The 3-amidopyrrolidin-4-one inhibitors were bound in the active site of t
he enzyme in two alternate directions. Epimerization issues associated with
the labile a-amino ketone diastereomeric center contained within these inh
ibitor classes has proven to limit their utility despite promising pharmaco
kinetics displayed in both series of compounds.