The paper examines the nature of health insurance contracts when insurance
companies pool high- and low-risk individuals. In a spatial product differe
ntiation model, the normal forces of competition induce quality provision,
but selection incentives induce insurers to under-provide quality. To offse
t selection incentives, the government can reimburse some of the insurers'
costs. However, such a subsidy can in some cases reduce quality further, as
well as discourage production efficiency. In such cases the optimal reimbu
rsement rate is negative. (C) 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserve
d.