The poorly reactive and dilated pupil observed in a comatose patient i
s often thought to represent an acute third nerve palsy owing to brain
herniation or aneurysm. In the well patient, however, the isolated di
lated pupil is unlikely to be owing to a third nerve palsy. It is more
commonly owing to other benign causes such as local iris sphincter ab
normalities, pharmacologic dilation, tonic pupil syndrome, or sympathe
tic irritation. This article presents a diagnostic flowchart to help t
he primary care physician analyze this problem and prevent costly and
unnecessary imaging of these patients.