The theoretical interpretation of lattice resolution in high-angle ann
ular dark-field images produced in a scanning transmission electron mi
croscope (STEM) has been a subject of controversy. A first-order pertu
rbation theoretical analysis is presented here, which shows that the c
ontrast in the image arises from large-angle multiphonon, incoherent s
cattering, which is atomic number dependent. The lattice resolution is
a consequence of coherently filling the objective aperture, and dynam
ical elastic diffraction preceding the large-angle multiphonon scatter
ing is not a necessary requirement. Elastic scattering to the higher o
rder Laue zone (HOLZ) is also shown to be negligible, compared with th
e incoherent scattering. Calculations from application of the theory a
re also presented. They show that lattice images formed using the high
-angle annular dark-field detector are sensitive to atomic number and
are relatively insensitive to defocus. Although high-angle annular dar
k-field lattice imaging appears to be simple, scattering into the high
-angle detector can only be approximately described by an incoherent i
maging model.