Govers [1992] showed that the flow velocity in rills eroding loose, nonlaye
red materials could be predicted from knowledge of discharge only (without
significant slope or soil effect). The objective of this paper is to invest
igate to what extent the observed slope independence of flow velocity in er
oding rills can be explained by the interaction between rill bed roughness
and flow hydraulics. In a laboratory study, two situations were compared: (
1) rills which can freely erode a uniform soil layer and (2) rills with a f
ixed bed geometry. During the experiments, rill discharge and flow velocity
were recorded. After each experiment, a detailed topographic survey of the
rill bed was carried out using a laser scanner. From these data the main h
ydraulic variables (mean values of flow depth, wetted perimeter, and hydrau
lic radius) were estimated. The experiments confirmed the slope independenc
e of rill flow velocities on mobile beds. When the bed is fixed, the flow v
elocity in rills is clearly slope-dependent. The slope independence of flow
velocity on mobile beds is due to a feedback between rill bed morphology a
nd flow conditions. The roughness amplitude (which was assessed from the st
andard deviation of corrected height values) and the frequency of macroroug
hness elements (which was assessed by counting the number of peaks per unit
length in a previously simplified longitudinal profiles) both increase and
tend to counteract the effect of the increase in slope gradient on rill fl
ow velocity. The final rill flow velocity appears to be characterized by a
constant average Froude number.