Sr. Kaufman, THE WORLD-WAR-II PLUTONIUM EXPERIMENTS - CONTESTED STORIES AND THEIR LESSONS FOR MEDICAL-RESEARCH AND INFORMED CONSENT, Culture, medicine and psychiatry, 21(2), 1997, pp. 161-197
During the Second World War medical researchers around the USA injecte
d 18 hospital patients with radioactive plutonium in order to learn it
s effects on the body. Two documents, a newspaper account and a univer
sity committee report, tell divergent stories of the scientists and pa
tients involved in that experiment. This article uses those documents
- plutonium narratives - as a catalyst for exploring the problematic r
epresentation of past human experimentation, assumptions of moral prog
ress in medical research, and the nature of informed consent today. In
formed consent is shown to be an evolving process and discursive pract
ice that cannot be understood apart from its historical and cultural e
mbeddedness.