Purpose: To report the results of primary radiotherapy for treatment of ana
l canal carcinoma from the University of Florida series and review issues r
elated to treatment of this disease.
Methods and Materials: Forty-nine patients were treated with primary radiat
ion therapy (RT) for cure, Patients had a minimum 2-year follow-up (median,
9.8 years). After 1990, patients with lesions of at least 3 cm also receiv
ed chemotherapy with fluorouracil (1000 mg/m(2)) plus cisplatin (100 mg/m(2
)) or mitomycin (10-15 mg/m(2)) if medically fit (n = 26), RT was delivered
with a 4-field box technique to deliver 45 Gy in 25 fractions. The inguina
l nodes were treated daily using electrons to supplement the dose in that r
egion to a total dose of 45 Gy if clinically negative or about 60 Gy if inv
olved. There were no planned breaks. A 10- to 15-Gy boost was delivered usi
ng interstitial iridium 192 implant (n = 32), en face Co-60 field (n = 5),
or external-beam photon fields (n = 11),
Results: Local control rates at 5 years were 100% for T1N0, 92% for T2N0 or
N1, 75% for T3N0, 57% for T4N0, 88% for T4N(pos) or T(any)N2-3, and 85% ov
erall. With surgical salvage, ultimate local control rates were 100%, 100%,
81%, 100%, and 88%, respectively, with 92% overall. Cause-specific surviva
l rates at 5 years were 100% for Stage I, 88% for Stage II, 100% for Stage
IIIA, and 70% for Stage IIIB. Absolute survival rates at 5 years were 62%,
68%, 100%, and 70%, Sphincter preservation rates were 83%, 79%, 75%, and 10
0% by stage and 81% overall, There was an improvement in local control with
the addition of chemotherapy in more advanced disease, but it was not sign
ificant. There was an increase in acute toxicity with the addition of chemo
therapy (12% greater than or equal to Grade 4) but not long-term toxicity,
Late toxicity requiring colostomy occurred in 6% of patients and consisted
of soft tissue necrosis,
Conclusions: The majority of patients with anal canal carcinoma can be trea
ted with curative intent using a sphincter-sparing approach of radiation wi
th or without chemotherapy even with advanced disease. With the addition of
chemotherapy to radiation, there is an increased risk of acute toxicity an
d about 1-2% incidence of toxic death. Smaller tumors (T1 and early T2) pro
bably do not require the addition of chemotherapy. (C) 2001 Elsevier Scienc
e Inc.