Jm. Albandar et al., Cigar, pipe, and cigarette smoking as risk factors for periodontal diseaseand tooth loss, J PERIODONT, 71(12), 2000, pp. 1874-1881
Background: Our purpose was to test the hypotheses that cigar and pipe smok
ing have significant associations with periodontal disease and cigar, pipe,
and cigarette smoking is associated with tooth loss. We also investigated
whether a history of smoking habits cessation may affect the risk of period
ontal disease and tooth loss.
Methods: A group of 705 individuals (21 to 92 years-old) who were among vol
unteer participants in the ongoing Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging we
re examined clinically to assess their periodontal status and tooth loss. A
structured interview was used to assess the participants' smoking behavior
s with regard to cigarettes, cigar, and pipe smoking status. For a given to
bacco product, current smokers were defined as individuals who at the time
of examination continued to smoke daily. Former heavy smokers were defined
as individuals who have smoked daily for 10 or more years and who had quit
smoking. Non-smokers included individuals with a previous history of smokin
g for less than 10 years or no history of smoking.
Results: Cigarette and cigar/pipe smokers had a higher prevalence of modera
te and severe periodontitis and higher prevalence and extent of attachment
loss and gingival recession than non-smokers, suggesting poorer periodontal
health in smokers. In addition, smokers had less gingival bleeding and hig
her number of missing teeth than non-smokers. Current cigarette smokers had
the highest prevalence of moderate and severe periodontitis (25.7%) compar
ed to former cigarette smokers (20.2%), and non-smokers (13.1%). The estima
ted prevalence of moderate and severe periodontitis in current or former ci
gar/pipe smokers was 17,6%. A similar pattern was seen for other periodonta
l measurements including the percentages of teeth with greater than or equa
l to5 mm attachment loss and probing depth, greater than or equal to3 mm gi
ngival recession, and dental calculus. Current, former, and non- cigarette
smokers had 5.1, 3,9, and 2.8 missing teeth, respectively. Cigar/pipe smoke
rs had on average 4 missing teeth. Multiple regression analysis also showed
that current tobacco smokers may have increased risks of having moderate a
nd severe periodontitis than former smokers. However, smoking behaviors exp
lained only small percentages (<5%) of the variances in the multivariate mo
dels.
Conclusion: The results suggest that cigar and pipe smoking may have simila
r adverse effects on periodontal health and tooth loss as cigarette smoking
. Smoking cessation efforts should be considered as a means of improving pe
riodontal health and reducing tooth loss in heavy smokers of cigarettes, ci
gars, and pipes with periodontal disease.