A lab-scale biofilm reactor for simultaneous removal of phosphorus and nitr
ate was operated for one and a half years. Despite using only well defined
synthetic wastewater and well defined operation, the activity varied signif
icantly over the months. It was speculated that microbial population shifts
were causing this phenomenon. This could also explain a sudden break down
of the process following a slight change in the operation. Over shorter per
iods of time (time-scale: days), the biofilm could be considered stable eno
ugh to perform series of comparable batch experiments. Batch experiments wi
th different start concentrations of acetate, nitrate or phosphate were con
ducted. These verified 0.5 and 0 order removal rates in the bulk water depe
nding on the concentration. This was taken as an indication of a zonation o
f the biofilm. Due to the measured Variability in the activity and due to t
he importance of the history of the bacteria when considering biological P
removal, an-line measurements are strongly recommended for research on this
subject. Microbial characterisation methods are recommended as an assistin
g tool in further research.