Objective: The present trial was originally designed to investigate the eff
ectiveness of comprehensive day hospital care in chronically ill elderly pa
tients. Another aim, reported here, was to investigate to what extent it is
possible to reduce polypharmacy and simplify drug regimens during the shor
t term tight control conditions of day hospital care.
Patients: All home care patients (n = 174, mean age 77 years) in a rural ar
ea, Kirkkonummi-Siuntio, in Finland,
Design and setting: Patients were randomised into 2 groups, one of which wa
s offered a 2-month period of day hospital care. Patients assumed to be non
compliant (because they did not want day hospital care) were also included
in order to see the effect of intervention in 'real-life'. The medications
of all participants were reviewed and counted during an in-home assessment
by a home nurse. In the intervention group, necessary revisions (dose reduc
tion, discontinuation, possible additions) were performed through the tight
monitoring of day hospital care and in co-operation with the patient. The
patients were followed up for 10 months after completion of the interventio
n programme.
Outcome measures: Number of prescribed medications, number of over-the-coun
ter (OTC) drugs, number of doses taken daily by the patients. Assessments w
ere performed at baseline, and after 2, 5 and 12 months.
Results: There were no significant changes in the number of prescribed medi
cations. In patients in day hospital care, the number of doses was reduced
significantly (p = 0.02) during the 2-month day hospital period compared wi
th the control group. However, the patients compensated for the reductions
by increasing the use of OTC drugs during the day hospital period (p = 0.05
). In addition, only 3 months after the trial, the number of drugs had alre
ady returned to the baseline level.
Conclusions: In real life it seems to be difficult to reduce polypharmacy i
n the elderly. Some drug reductions may be achieved with tight control unde
r trial conditions, but when the intervention ceases the number of drugs us
ed soon returns to its earlier level.